| Gillette Returns
to the Super Bowl
Published: January 26, 2004
By STUART ELLIOTT
DURING the Super Bowl, Madison Avenue will cast a clear eye
for the straight guy - as in straight to the store, to buy
stuff.
The lineup of brands to be promoted Sunday during the CBS
broadcast of Super Bowl XXXVIII is taking on more of a male
appeal than has been the case in recent years.
Among those to be featured in commercials, costing an estimated
record price of $2.3 million for each 30 seconds, will be
the Gillette shaving products, making their first Super Sunday
appearance in a decade. Others include two drugs that treat
erectile dysfunction, Cialis and Levitra;
Cadillac, Chevrolet, Dodge and Mitsubishi automobiles;
and Budweiser and Bud Light beers. There will even be a spot
from Procter & Gamble, for Charmin bathroom tissue, with
football players.
And most of the movies likely to be advertised during the
game by the Columbia, Touchstone, Universal and Warner Brothers
studios are aimed at men: "The Alamo;" "The
Bourne Supremacy," with Matt Damon; "Catwoman,"
with Halle Berry; "The Chronicles of Riddick," with
Vin Diesel; "Starsky & Hutch"; and "Troy,"
with Brad Pitt.
"We don't go to the Super Bowl every year," said
Peter K. Hoffman, president for blades and razors at the Gillette Company in Boston. "When we have big news,
we will go to the showcase event that more men watch"
than any other television program in a typical year.
The news from Gillette for 2004, he added, is the introduction
of an updated version of a brand-image campaign, carrying
the theme "The best a man can get," that originally
appeared in 1989.
The remaking of the campaign to play up what Mr. Hoffman
calls "the feeling of Gillette" comes as the company
confronts the strongest challenge in years from its longtime
rival in the shaving category, Schick-Wilkinson Sword, which
has the new Schick Quattro four-bladed razor.
"This is a critical time for Gillette," said Jonah
Disend, president at Redscout in New York, a corporate strategy
consultant. "It had a superior product for so long that
men bought into Gillette whether or not they bought into the
image."
"Now that Gillette's facing much more competition,"
Mr. Disend said, "it needs people to buy the brand as
much as the product."
A 60-second commercial from the Gillette agency, BBDO Worldwide
in New York, part of the Omnicom Group, is intended to present Gillette to the estimated
50 million men who watch the game, Mr. Hoffman said, as "the
company that's the best in the shaving business for men, from
a product-performance point of view and from an emotional
understanding of men's needs to look, feel and be their best."
The tilt toward male viewers represents a return to old-school
form. From the first Super Bowl in 1967 through the 1980's,
most commercials were for products like cars, shaving cream,
motor oil and beer. "Back in the days when men were men,"
Bernice Kanner writes in a new book, "The Super Bowl
of Advertising: How the Commercials Won the Game" (Bloomberg
Press), the "target was the Archie Bunker man."
That began to change after the big game became more of an
annual unofficial national holiday, with millions of women
joining men at Super Bowl Sunday parties, and more of a showcase
for creative advertising from marketers like Frito-Lay, MasterCard,
Pepsi-Cola and Visa, selling to both sexes. Indeed, in most
years more women watch the Super Bowl than watch the Academy
Awards, despite that show's common description as the Super
Bowl for women. The true Super Bowl for women, it turns out,
is the Super Bowl.
In fact, it is the presence of so many women in the audience
that is attracting Cialis into the Super Bowl, said Carole
Copeland, a spokeswoman for Eli Lilly & Company in Indianapolis,
which is marketing the drug to consumers in a joint venture
with the Icos Corporation.
"What's a better place to be than where men - and their
partners - are enjoying the game and paying attention to the
advertising?" Ms. Copeland asked. The content of the
Cialis commercial, being created by Grey Worldwide in New
York, part of the Grey Global Group, is being kept under wraps
until the game, she said.
Gillette, on the other hand, plans to release copies of its
commercial today, and offered a preview of the spot last week.
The fast-paced commercial uses far less traditional imagery
than before; the men are younger, for instance, and there
are many more models who are neither blond nor white. Also,
the script that is read by a voice-over announcer, as well
as the lyrics of a jingle heard in the spot, are much more
conversational, colloquial and casual than in previous commercials.
"It's a guy trying to express to other guys what it's
like to feel great," said Al Merrin, vice chairman and
executive creative director at BBDO New York.
"It's quite a change, a big step forward into this century,"
he added, "because it's more contemporary, more sexy,
and the images are a lot more inclusive; you don't have to
be the perfect guy."
Mr. Merrin said the goal for Gillette advertising was twofold:
to convince men that Gillette is "the best at what it
does, product-wise; and to make the brand emotionally acceptable
and likable."
"But we'd been losing touch" with the brand goal,
he added, so "the assignment was to re-energize, contemporize
and emotionalize it."
Mr. Merrin and Mr. Hoffman said the plans to update the Gillette
brand image, and kick off the effort with a Super Bowl spot,
were in development well before the Quattro introduction by
Schick in September.
"Yes, there's some competition," Mr. Hoffman said.
"But, our response to Quattro is the Mach3 Turbo Champion
razor and a retail display blitz in the fourth quarter."
The Champion is a variant of the top-of-the-line Mach3 Turbo.
Gillette also plans a May introduction of a battery-operated
razor, the Mach3 M3 Power, he added.
Gillette has responded aggressively on the legal front, too,
charging in a lawsuit that by selling Quattro, Schick's parent,
Energizer Holdings,
infringed the patent of Gillette's best-selling Mach3 products.
On Jan. 15, a federal district court judge denied a Gillette
motion for a preliminary injunction that would order Quattro
razors and blades removed from retail outlets.
The judge ruled that Quattro could be sold until the Gillette
patent-infringement lawsuit was decided. Gillette appealed
the decision the next day to a federal appeals court.
Schick in turn has sued Gillette for false advertising, charging
that Gillette can no longer assert it offers "the best
a man can get" because Quattro provides superior shaves.
"We sometimes feel like we've run into the schoolyard
bully on our way home," said Joseph E. Lynch, the president
of Schick, based in Milford, Conn. "We don't view ourselves
as a threat" to Gillette, he said.
A dogfight between giant corporations - now that's something
that appeals to some American men as much as, if not more
than, a mere football game.
Source : http://www.nytimes.com
|